2012
1st: Draft? He Said Ryely -- Eric J
2nd: Forty -- Chris R
3rd: Turn & Burn -- Ryan R
4th: T B D -- Dan D
5th: DoubleCorkageAction -- Thad O

2011
1st: Mac Daddy -- Michael M
2nd: Auto Equals Awesome -- Eric J
3rd: LickHillistogetPercy -- Dad D
4th: Two drink max -- Kevin K
5th: Twenty -- Chris R

2010
1st: Lost Wolf -- Kevin G
2nd: Mac Daddy -- Michael M
3rd: Chinese Owned -- Kevin K
4th: Crash & Burn -- Thad O
5th: Looking4newfriends -- Mike J

2009
1st: Martz-Free Zone -- Brad J
2nd: Lost Wolf -- Kevin G
3rd: Bowtie Beatdown -- Thad O
4th: Paying Other Ways -- Kevin K
5th: Super Hotlanta -- Ryan R

2008
1st: Hard Hat Attack -- Thad O
2nd: Draft Dozers -- Dan D
3rd: Abatar -- Michael M
4th: Listen 2 Uncle Kevin -- Kevin K
5th: It's a Buick BITCH! -- Chris R

2007
1st: AllabouttheBenjamins -- Mike J -- Trophy party
2nd: Draft Dominator -- Dan D
3rd: Take your Medicine -- Chris R
4th: Lettuce Engine -- Michael M
5th: Brut Force -- Thad O

2006
1st: Twist of Mash -- Thad O -- Picture of Thad w/ Trophy
2nd: DanceSystemsActivate -- Chris R
3rd: Game Over -- Kevin K
4th: Skinny White Guys -- Brad J
5th: Dutch Picnic -- Keith R

2005
1st: Scotch on the Rocks -- Ryan R
2nd: The Whizzinators -- Mike J
3rd: ChickenClock.com -- Kevin K
4th: Note to Self -- Brad J
5th: New Kicks -- Thad O

2004
1st: Doubtful Damsels -- Dan D
2nd: Always a Bridesmaid -- Michael "Mac" M
3rd: Flopping Straights -- Thad O
4th: Scotch on the Rocks -- Ryan R
5th: FF Sniper -- Kevin K

2003
1st: Renees Trophy Party -- Brad J
2nd: Axis of Sweetness -- Michael "Mac"
3rd: AAAssault -- Ryan Robeson
4th: Pagoda Inferno -- Thad O
5th: Cartjackers -- Chris R

2002
1st: RiccisLawnFurniture -- Mike J
2nd: The Sweet Spot -- Michael M
3rd: Orange Crush -- Keith Robeson
4th: Chicks w/ Boyfriends -- Eric J
5th: Deuce-Duce -- Ryan R

2001
1st: Scotch on the Rocks -- Ryan Robeson
2nd: Oooak - Towwwn -- Kevin K
3rd: Draft Dodgers -- Mike Johnson
4th: Jailboy Allstars -- Brad Johnsen
5th: Legal in Vermont -- Eric Johnson

2000
1st: Yipesft -- Kevin K
2nd: Getting Written On -- Eric Johnson
3rd: Muff Divers -- Thad
4th: Scotch on the Rocks -- Ryan Robeson
5th: Big Mac -- Mike McCarroll

All time standings: (5 pts for 1st, 1 pts for 5th)

Michael M	27
Thad O		26
Kevin K		25
Ryan R		22
Mike J		18
Dan D		18
Brad J		16
Eric J		16
Chris R		14
Kevin G		9
Keith R		4
Fed F		0
Hashem N	0
Scott F		0
T-Bone F	0
Dr. F		0

Most appearances on the trophy:

Michael M	6
Thad		5
Kevin K		5
Mike J		4
Dan D		4
Ryan R		4
Chris*		3 / 4*
Eric J		3
Brad		2
Kevin G		2
Keith		1